Semi-solid separator selection / 2026-11-20
Selecting a separator for semi-solid cells: mechanical retention matters before peak strength
In a semi-solid cell the peak puncture strength is only a threshold. What decides whether the cell still holds together under thermal duty is the retention of that strength after heat treatment. This article sets out the order of checks and the test conditions behind each figure.
The note
Figures are quoted with their test condition and standard; project-specific data is confirmed one to one at the sample stage.
Start with retention, not with peak strength
A nominal puncture strength tells you whether a separator can be pierced by a dendrite at room temperature. It is a threshold, not a description of a semi-solid cell, which spends its life under thermal duty. The order of checks should be: whether dimensions survive heat treatment, then how much of the mechanical strength is retained in the same window, and only then the peak value itself.
Mixing the three is the common mistake. Depending on the cell architecture and the heat treatment window, the retention figure can differ by a factor of several, so a number without its condition is not comparable.
First dimension: thickness against the space budget
Separator thickness takes directly out of the active material budget. Once the energy density target is fixed, the order of trade-offs has to be settled before the coating scheme is chosen: bracket the thickness range that can be allocated, then decide how much mechanical retention that range must deliver, and only then move to a model.
Within one thickness range the difference between a single-side and a double-side coated scheme is not only about thermal margin. It also shows up as the stability of the interface during assembly, which can become the binding constraint before the peak figures do.
Second dimension: mechanical retention in the heat window
In the 150 °C / 0.5 h window, the double-side coated scheme retains 40-60% of its puncture strength; in the 180 °C / 0.5 h window it still retains more than 20%. Both figures come from the company test report with fixed conditions and a fixed acceptance basis, so batches can be compared one by one.
Retention and thermal shrinkage are independent conclusions and must not be inferred from each other. A thermal shrinkage of 1-2% (180 °C / 30 min, air atmosphere, GB/T 36363-2018) is a statement about dimensional stability. Retention is a statement about how much mechanical performance survives the treatment. Stable dimensions with a marked drop in mechanics, or the reverse, are both possible combinations.
Third dimension: interfacial adhesion on a checkable basis
Interfacial adhesion is judged by peel strength. Under GB/T 7122-96 (peel strength of high-strength adhesives, floating roller method) the company's internal acceptance threshold is >30 N/m. Test data show that both the single-side and the double-side coated schemes meet that threshold, and that the double-side scheme meets it stably across a wider range of process conditions.
The acceptance threshold and the measured value are different things and must not be interchanged. Use the threshold to compare suppliers side by side, and the measured value to trace a batch back through time.
What to check when a model is chosen
Six models are on sale, with nominal total thicknesses of 9 / 11 / 13 / 14 µm, covering single-side, double-side and semi-solid schemes. A useful order of checks is: whether thickness and areal density fall in the target range; whether the shrinkage acceptance condition matches the window your application requires; which retention band applies; and whether air permeability and porosity meet the wetting demand.
When all four line up, the discussion has reached a verifiable level. The coating composition and process parameters are company trade secrets and are not published; they can be provided in a one-to-one technical discussion.
Related pages
To discuss a parameter range for a specific cell architecture, contact the technical team directly.